Showing posts with label macarons. Show all posts
Showing posts with label macarons. Show all posts

Monday, March 21, 2011

Macarons on a rainy day

I refuse to be a victim of humidity.
It was a rainy day in Singapore (read: 100% relative humidity), and I wanted to test my theory that heating egg whites in the swiss macron method causes them to lose moisture, and so has the same effect of aging them. My last batch of successful macarons were made with whites that were aged over 2 nights under my air-con, resulting in 5% loss in weight. So theoretically, if the heating process in the swiss method leads to at least 5% loss in weight of the whites, then I should be able to make a successful batch using fresh whites.

An experiment ensues. 
Setting a bowl of freshly cracked egg white atop a pot of water, and swirling it periodically to distribute heat evenly, I measured the difference in weight before heating vs. at 50 deg c (the stipulated temperature  in the swiss method). The weight loss was 5%! 

So if you want to make macarons without the wait involved in aging the whites, use the swiss method. I consider this batch a double success because fresh whites were used, and it was a very humid day. So humid that 1h 50 min of sitting, with fans blowing, was still not long enough for a crust to form, leading to cracks in the first batch. The second batch, which I let sit for 3h 15 min, were successful. 




Fan speed = 3

Tops not fully crusted even after sitting for 1h 15 min, so cracked upon baking

Patience was the order of the day. These sat for 3h 15 min and formed a stronger crust

Thursday, November 18, 2010

Battle of the Macaron Meringue Methods

Question 1: Which type of meringue produces the best macarons- Italian, French, or Swiss? 

Italian

French

Swiss!


From least to most compact feet: Swiss, French, Italian. Thus I think the Swiss way produces the prettiest feet. 

An overview of the 3 meringue methods:
Italian- The most fiddly. Pour 118 deg c sugar syrup into half-whipped egg whites.
French- The most direct. Simply whip egg whites with sugar to form the meringue
Swiss- The in-between. In a bowl set above a pot of simmering water, hand whisk egg whites till 50 deg c, then continue whisking with electric beaters, while adding the sugar.

I used to favour the Italian method, then the French, and now I've settled on the Swiss method because I find that it allows adding the least amount of sugar into the meringue, so the shells don't end up sickeningly sweet. For me, the problem with store-bought macrons is that they're all too sweet, so I get put off after eating 2. In a sense, I don't want the process of eating macarons to be a guilt trip!

In the Swiss method, heating the whites (till 50 deg c) stabilises the meringue a little which means that the meringue can reach the same level of stability with less sugar, compared to the French method. The concentrated sugar syrup used in the Italian method also limits how low you can go with the sugar. Taste wise, the Swiss way yields eggy rather than almondy shells, which I like as I've never been a fan of almonds.


Question 2: Is it better to use parchment or those reusable silicone sheets?

Baked on parchment

Baked on silicone sheet
Left: Baked on silicone sheet; Right: Baked on parchment
As you can see, parchment gives more generous feet. Also, silicone sheets are much more slippery and rapping the tray on the counter to get rid of large air bubbles caused the shells to shift a little, resulting in baked shell caps that were not in line with the feet. Reminded me of old men with ill-fitting dentures! So if you use silicone sheets, better not to rap the trays on the counter, and handle with care when moving them.

Question 3: what caused this little fella to split?


Answer: The top was still a little wet when it went into the oven. The tops were quite bumpy after piping, so I used a finger dabbed in water to smooth out the tops. After 45 min, this one still wasn't dry- must have used a little too much water! But why did I have to smooth them over in the first place? I hypothesised that the bumpy tops were caused by adding too much Almond Meal, which also were not ground fine enough. The next time, I ground the Almond Meal with the Icing Sugar, and added less of these to the meringue (recipe below). As you can see, this resulted in smoother tops (blue macaron) vs. bumpy yellow macrons. But it's still not as smooth as I'd like because my old food processor has blunt blades. I would love a new one for Chirstmas- preferably one with a feeding tube! *hint hint*


After baking macarons 4 times in 5 days, I'm going on a macaron break. I may just bake them again when I get a new food processor. But for now, time to study for my final exams at SMU, and to enjoy quality time with D, who is returning tomorrow (finally!) :)

Recipe for 18 Macarons (ie. 36 shells)
47g Almond Meal
83g Icing Sugar

50g Aged egg whites
1/2 Tsp cream of tar tar
17g Caster Sugar

Gel colouring: 2 toothpick dips (dip 1 toothpick into colouring, smear onto electric beaters. Repeat with a fresh toothpick)

1. Weigh and sift together almond meal and icing sugar
2. Weigh out egg whites and caster sugar into separate bowls
3. Add cream of tar tar to the bowl of egg whites and set the bowl over a pot of simmering water. Whisk until temperature of whites reaches 50-55 deg c (This took 7 min over low heat, by which time the whites were almost at soft peak stage)
4. Remove from the pot, and continue whisking with electric beaters, sprinkling in the caster sugar. 
5. Add the colouring then stop whisking when it's reached firm peaks. (Total electric whisking time was 1 min on speed 1, followed by 2 min on speed 2 with my Phillips handheld electric beaters)
6. Fold in the almond meal + icing sugar mixture in 5 batches, ensuring they are almost fully absorbed before adding more. After adding the last batch, fold about 4 more times to achieve a supple ribbony batter.
7. Fill the piping bag and pipe circles 1 inch in diameter onto baking tray lined with parchment or silicone sheets
8. Let the trays sit until the tops and sides of the macaron shells are no longer tacky (for me, this took 45 min in my bedroom with the air con on)
9. 20 min before baking, preheat oven to 160 deg c with one rack on the lowest rung, and another rack lined with aluminium foil on the topmost rung.
10. Bake the macarons for 24 min. In my oven, feet appeared after 5 min, and kept developing till the 10 min mark. Then they started to retreat a little and stabilised at the 12 min mark. This grow-then-retreat behaviour is normal for macaron feet.
11. When done, remove from oven and pop into freezer to cool for 2 min, then gently peel parchment/silicone sheet away from macarons and cool upside down on cooling rack.

Note: every oven is different, so you have to experiment to find out how long your macarons should stay in the oven such that the bottoms are baked enough to peel off the parchment, but not too long that the tops or bottoms are burnt. The aluminium shield at the topmost rung will prevent the tops from burning so you can concentrate on getting the bottoms right.
 .........................................................................................................................................

Curious glob of lemon curd!





Wednesday, October 13, 2010

Macaron class

Last week was break week at school, so I went for a macaron-making class at BakinCow. I'm no stranger to macaron-making, but her macs look better than mine (especially the feet) , so I decided to give it a go! 

                         BakinCow's coffee macaron             My chocolate sea-salt macarons

She used the French method and here are my main takeaways:

1. You can use fresh egg whites
2. Fibreglass baking sheets are awesome. They produce better mac bottoms than parchment. Parchment requires longer cooking time for the bottoms to be non-tacky, by which time the tops may have an undesirable tan. So fibreglass baking sheets allow you to concentrate on baking your macs to the right internal texture, without worrying about whether they can come off the sheet.
3. More sugar in the meringue = taller feet

I went home and compared the following ingredient ratios in her recipe and the one I use from Not so Humble Pie, measured by weight: 
- wet ingredients/dry ingredients
- egg white/(almond flour + icing sugar)
- caster sugar/egg white.

The only difference found was for the ratio of caster sugar/egg white. 0.5 (BakinCow) vs 0.3 (mine). I therefore conclude that the shorter feet on my macs result from less sugar in the meringue. Bumping up the sugar should produce more elegant feet!

Not firm enough... keep mixing!
Hollow shells
According to Syrup & Tang, a possible cause of hollow shells is low baking temperature (140 deg c in this case). The macaron batter was concentrated at the bottom of the shell, making it hard on the teeth. 

The class also proved that you can make macs with fresh whites, although I'm not sure if this results in a less desirable texture than when aged whites are used, because of the higher moisture content in fresh whites. Next time, I'll bump up the sugar for the meringue and use fresh whites. Oh, and I need to get my hands on some fibreglass sheets. Stay tuned for the results!


..................................................................................................................................................

The BakinCow class is excellent for beginners as it is conducted at home, making the idea and process of macaron-making less daunting. She also makes tofu cheesecakes (which I heard are awesome), and conducts other cooking workshops. Check out her website here.
                                          


Tuesday, August 17, 2010

Dark chocolate sea salt macarons

Final Semester starts tomorrow. What to do? Make macarons!

After reading Ms. Humble's blog about the French method of macaron-making, I started having doubts about my preference for the Italian method. Especially after the Italian way yielded a failed batch of macarons yesterday. And since it's almost always humid (Singapore is a mere degree North of the equator), it may be best to avoid introducing any water to the meringue (which is required by the Italian way).

So. Armed with my new stainless steel bowl, wilton gel colouring and parchment (only $3.90 for 20 metres woohoo!), I thought "Tres bien!" and set about the the French way.

The result?

Ce'sont tres bon!

I used the recipe on Ms. Humble's blog, dividing it into 4 to yield 6 macarons (12 shells). I baked them all at 150 degrees c, on the lowest oven rung.



Baking times from left to right: 21 minutes (burnt), 18 minutes (bottom slightly burnt but not tacky), and 21 minutes with wooden spoon wedged in the oven door when the fan came on (bottom too tacky). 

Conclusion: The best of the lot is Mr. middle- 18 minutes at 150 degrees c, with a closed door even when the fan came on (contrary to much internet macaron rhetoric). However, the bottoms were a bit burnt. I'll wait till tomorrow to see if this affects their taste.


Putting my babies to sleep


.......................................................................................................................................................


The next day...

Good morning, my little ones!

These shells were the same kind as Mr. Middle (see above post).  The circumference at the centre of the mac was a darker colour due to the burnt bottoms. Looks slightly unappetising.

These shells were the same kind as Mr. Extreme Right (see above post). Evenly coloured but a tad too moist for my liking.

They were a little less sweet than macs made with Italian meringue, and as D puts it, more poppy. The shells were also less dense, with more crumb. I didn't observe a difference between the skin thickness of shells made with both methods- both yielded satisfyingly thin skins. I'll have to find a way to cook the inside like Mr. Middle and at the same time, not discolour the bottoms!

The salt really adds an excellent kick, drawing out those salivary juices and making them scream "more!, more!"

Next time, I'll use 85% chocolate because the 70% still proved too sweet, perhaps because salt has the ability to make bitter taste sweet- so says Heston Blumenthal. I belive him.

Friday, June 11, 2010

Chocolate Macarons: A Picturebook


















These aren’t the prettiest replications of them temperamental confections but still decent, I’d say! I modified Pierre Hermé’s basic macaron recipe slightly to accommodate the cocoa. And I don't have egg white powder but using very aged whites (7 days old) seems to have made up for it.


Ingredients for 20 macarons (40 shells)
100g Almond flour


95.5g Icing sugar
 4.5g Dutch processed cocoa

2 x 37.5g egg whites, aged 7 days
¼ tsp cream of tar tar
100g caster sugar
25g water

Note: I've used this recipe successfully with 3 day-old whites, but they were a little moist and I had to sit them out to dry. If you're using 3 day-old whites, try reducing the water to 22g.

Prep
For the baking:
Set up oven trays with baking paper, cut to size. Since my trays are black and so will not show pencilled circles, I put a plain sheet of baking paper over the circle template. Added benefit: reusing the template so I don’t have to go mad drawing circles.

For the piping:
Stand piping bag in a glass, with the end open ready to receive the batter.

For the whipping:
Plug in and have electric beater ready. Have nearby a bowl suitable for whipping your whites, and cream of tar tar.

Making the shells
1. Weigh then sift the almond flour, icing sugar and cocoa. The “right” way is to process these before sifting, but I lack a food processor. And I can’t bear to waste any ingredients, so I dumped the big bits in too. 















2. Weigh the sugar and water into a pot, clip on candy thermometer, and set them on the stove.















3. Weigh the whites out into 2 small bowls. Pour 1 portion into the whipping bowl, and add the cream of tar tar. Just before turning the stove on for the sugar syrup, give it a stir. Turn the stove on to start the sugar syrup. Pour the other portion of whites into the tant pour tant and mix in concentric circles till well combined.















4. When the thermometer reaches around 85 degrees c, start whipping the whites. When the whites just reach stiff peaks, the thermometer should read about 118 degrees c. Turn off stove and quickly pour in syrup. Keep whipping until the bowl is just warm to touch, about 1 minute. When whipping, it helps to spin the bowl around instead of moving the beaters so you get a good view of what’s going on inside, and so you give all areas inside equal attention.













5. With a rubber spatula, add 1/3 of the meringue to the tant pour tant-whites mixture. Quickly loosen it with a chopping motion, sweeping it from time to time (not too violent!). When the mixture seems uniformly mixed, add rest of the meringue.



6. Fold in meringue by sweeping spatula under mixture toward you and bringing it over the top, while turning the bowl to attack it from different angles. Scrape down the sides from time to time. I find the best way to check if you’ve got the batter to the right stage is to do a test pipe with a small portion. If it is still peaky, squeeze it out and mix more.
















Test pipe: too peaky. Needs to be folded further












                
 I stopped folding at this stage


7. When you’re happy with the batter, dot some on the perimeter of baking tray to stick the 2 sheets of baking paper down (the one with circles and the blank one). Then pipe! Keep nozzle tip in the piped batter until ready to pull away or it’ll look like one macaron stacked atop another. Don’t pull away too quickly or the tip of the batter will break off, leaving a crater.

8. Let sit till sides and top surface don’t leave a mark on your finger when touched.


9. Turn oven to 160 degrees celcius, to the mode that gives top and bottom heat (no fan). When preheated, stack the tray of macarons onto another empty tray and put these in the oven at the lowest rack and wish them well (I always find myself saying “all the best my babies!”). After 4 min, remove empty bottom tray. At 9 ½ min, insert an empty oven tray into topmost oven shelf to block off some heat so macaron tops don’t burn. At 14 min, remove macarons, let stand for 20 sec and poke gently at the feet. If they hold their shape, it’s done! If not, return to oven for another minute.










Batch #1 at 7.5 min











Batch #2 at 5min. Although from the same batter, these sat for 15 min longer as they waited for batch #1 to bake, which made their feet growth more forthcoming.

10. When macarons are done, let stand for a minute to cool and harden slightly, making it easier to remove. Holding the macaron in question, peel baking paper away from its base and put on cooling rack.

I-can’t-afford-Valrhona Chocolate Ganache (for about 20 macarons)
I brought Valrhona Jivara and Guanaja chocolate to the counter to pay, but returned them when I realised they were not on offer. I just couldn’t bear to pay $21 for chocolate! Instead, I bought 2 blocks of Lindt for $7.

50g Lindt 70% Madagascar chocolate
40g Lindt 40% Milk chocolate
100g cooking cream
3 Tbsp thick cream
1. Put chocolates into a medium ovenproof bowl and soften them in the microwave. When done, bowl should be warm to touch, not hot. If too hot, let cool before incorporating the cooking cream.
2. Put cooking cream into a pan on very low heat, swirling around to ensure even heat distribution.
3. When cream is warmish to touch, remove from heat and pour onto chocolate in a thin stream, whisking continuously until smooth and cool.
4. Add thick cream. Whisk till mixture is airy.

Putting it all together
Piping nice rounds of filling ensures that it spreads out evenly when you press the shells together, so they look good from all side angles.














Notes:
1. What works for my oven may not work for yours, so do little test batches. I find that with a fan-forced oven, the macarons rise rapidly only to collapse halfway through. If the fan comes on in your oven, wedge a wet wooden spoon in the oven door to reduce air pressure on the macarons.

















Disorganised cracks:
Too little top heat because but an empty oven tray on the rack above too early

If there's too much top heat, they'll look sunburnt.

2. The correct sugar syrup temperature at which to start your meringue varies depending on the size of your pot and fire. 85 degrees is just a guide; experiment to see what works for you. However, it’s better to keep the syrup than the meringue waiting.

3. I find that the above recipe size is just nice. Do too big a batch and it’ll be hard to get the macaron batter evenly mixed. Do too small a batch and the sugar syrup will be problematic because the syrup won’t be deep enough to get a good reading on the thermometer.

4. Once preheated, don’t keep your oven waiting or the temperature will start to fluctuate.
 ...................................................................................................

The next big challenge is to make some macarons at home in humid Singapore. My more successful attempts have been made in Adelaide, where it's nice and dry. D (boyfriend who wishes to remain mysterious anonymous) has requested for Durian macarons. But P.U. I gag at the taste of durians (last time I accidentally ate some in an unsuspecting glutinous rice ball, the tears came down). I'll make shells with yellow food colouring, then he's on his own for the filling and eating. And no goodnight kisses, please.